Bernard -- It sounds like you are against the bills that are being proposed by the Demo's right now. But if you are against them, let me ask you this:
What is the solution to the many uninsured people that are currently out there? Take the guy has no insurance. He has a catastrophic illness or injury. He requires a lot of medical care. He can't pay the bill. The hospital, the ambulance company, and the doctor all have to write off his bill. These costs don't just go away. They get passed on to people like me who have health insurance. This raises my annual premium. It's money out of my pocket.
If you are against the current proposals that fix this by forcing everyone to be insured, how do you propose we fix this problem?
Thanks.
***
i thought my friend had some very good questions and wanted to share this with all my friends.
How the Freedom to Contract Protects Insurability
Paul Hsieh
In a free market, profit-seeking businessmen would likely sell insurance coverage to individuals with preexisting conditions for an appropriate price, just as they would seek to meet substantial demand for any service if profitable. However, in the unlikely event that some individuals sought to purchase a policy that covered preexisting conditions, and no insurer would sell them such a policy, they would still have a viable alternative. They would be free to form their own risk pool with other like-minded individuals willing to share those risks. They would be free to create their own insurance company.
In fact, many Americans have already formed private pools in which members voluntarily share each other's health-care costs. For instance, more than 100,000 American Christians are members of "health-care sharing ministries"—arrangements whereby members pay a monthly fee to the ministries, which in turn distribute that money to other members facing expensive medical bills. Such groups typically accept members who meet certain religious and lifestyle requirements regardless of preexisting medical conditions.
Unfortunately, these health-care sharing ministries currently cannot guarantee payments to their members, because the government would then treat them as insurance companies5 and subject them to myriad onerous state and federal regulations that specify what prices they may charge, what benefits they must offer, and which customers they must accept.6 The only thing preventing individuals from creating their own contractually binding risk pools today is the government...
a friend writes:
ReplyDelete>The hospital, the ambulance company,
> and the doctor all have to write off
> his bill. These costs don't just go
> away. They get passed on to people
> like me who have health insurance.
Why would "the hospital, the ambulance company and the doctor" pass the cost to your insurance company? It's their cost, not the insurance company's cost. Why would an insurance compny accept the cost of an uninsured patient who defaults on a payment?
This does not seem to a problem for other industries. If someone defaults on a payment, a company will sell the debt to a collection agency. And the debtor is reported to a credit agency. What the company does not do is confiscate money from all other customers to pay the debt of one deadbeat customer.
One solution is for "the hospital, the ambulance company and the doctor" to buy their own insurance to mitigate the risk of defaulting patients.
To think that the solution to this problem is to use the coercive force of government to simply violate everyone else's individual rights is unacceptable. Especially when it is the government that restricts the free market options available to private businesses in the first place. The answer is not to increase government interference but to completely remove government interference in the economy and let independent businessmen determine their own fate in a free, unregulated marketplace.
Bernard – here’s how I answer these questions:
ReplyDeleteQ: What is the solution to the many uninsured people that are currently out there?
Medicaid already exists as a government program to provide health care to poor Americans (and Illegals) who do not have Insurance.
It’s a failed programs hundred of BILLIONS of dollars in debt, and it was essentially a government-run health insurance program – just like the one Obama is proposing we nationalize and force everyone on.
The solution is for Americans to pay for their OWN health care. You have to pay for the food you choose to eat – the place you choose to live – why do we think we can have our neighbors pay for our health care? Pay for it yourself. Make payment arrangements. I do. I have no insurance. When I pay in cash – I get a discount. I check the bills to make sure I’m not being charged $20 for an aspirin. I let God be my insurer – and if I am in need of care, I will most likely make payments as my wife and I have been during the last seven years after her bout with cancer.
The solution is ALWAYS to choose and do for oneself if you value liberty. If you empower government to do it for you – you will become a slave.
Q: Take the guy has no insurance. He has a catastrophic illness or injury. He requires a lot of medical care. He can't pay the bill. The hospital, the ambulance company, and the doctor all have to write off his bill.
That is what Medicaid was supposed to take care of. The bloat and embezzlement has bankrupted it. Government mandates have driven rates to the moon. Telling a doctor he HAS to treat those who have no ability to pay is going to cause him to raise his rates in order to cover the costs he is forced to incur.
Q: These costs don't just go away. They get passed on to people like me who have health insurance. This raises my annual premium. It's money out of my pocket.
You can blame the trial lawyers and trival malpractice lawsuits in the billions of dollars in awarded damages for that. You can also blame the government’s mandate that doctors treat ANYONE – even if they are Illegal Aliens.
Q: If you are against the current proposals that fix this by forcing everyone to be insured, how do you propose we fix this problem?
What if I choose NOT to be insured? What if I want to pay in cash for my own care? Why will you rob me of that liberty?
This boondoggle IS NOT a fix. It is a final death nail for liberty in this country. I do not accept the premise that our healthcare is in need of “fixing”. It is the best in the world. What needs “fixing” is getting the government OUT of healthcare and private industry by fixing the Medicaid and Medicare programs that government ran into the ground.
Now you people tell us that after the examples of how government mismanaged Medicare and Medicaid – that you now want them to run EVERYONE’S health care insurance??
No thanks.